Investor's Corner
Oil Prices Sinking Tesla Motors Stock?
As I was watching a recent webinar on forward-looking trending tools for stocks, the moderator popped Tesla Motors stock chart on the screen to demonstrate the Fibonacci retracement and Ichimoku tools. Perfect timing, I’m a long investor in Tesla Motors stock and what about these downward oil prices?
Financial media sites are in a tizzy regarding oil prices plummeting—Saudis pulling the strings—and how this poses a big hurt for electric car industry sales and, of course, Tesla Motors stock price. Sine I cover the oil and gas industry for the Chicago-based Automation World magazine, the Saudis’ primary “displacement” target is U.S. shale.
Fracking shale plays are very expensive due to the fact that oil and gas drilling companies have to setup so many wells in order to find shale sweet spots. Plus, these small-to-medium sized drillers are financially over-leveraged and need barrel prices to be somewhere around $80 a barrel in order to be profitable. That’s not going to happen for some time, did I say “displacement.”
However, it does begs the question whether there is a decent correlation between high gas prices and electric car sales in the last four years, and will lower gas prices doom Tesla Motors’s stock price for the near-term or long-term?
Source: Energy Information Agency
As a Energy Information Agency chart shows above, there’s not a direct correlation between sales and increase gas prices. However, I believe some EV automakers will take a hit from really low gas prices in 2015–say $2.10-2.20– but not Tesla Motors.
Why? Tesla Motors owners are not obsessed with the price of power for their car, compared to a Volt or Leaf owner is my theory, and this car just won the award for the highest satisfaction from Consumer Reports, two years running.
Plus, Americans are buying more expensive cars, north of $50,000. TrueCar just this week released data on buying patterns and showed:
From January through November 931,064 vehicles were sold in the U.S. with average price above $50,000, a whopping 30.8 percent increase compared to the same period last year, according to TrueCar.
So with lower oil prices soon to be a non-issue or baked into Tesla’s current stock price, is it attractive at $210 or lower? How long will this downward, selling pressure last?
Ishimoku technicals (forward-looking indicators) point to new lows being tested in the near term, such as the $203 level. So Tesla shorting could continue and recent data shows 23% of Tesla stock owners were shorting in November.
According to John Del Vecchio and Tom Jacobs’ book What’s Behind the Numbers? (via a Nasdaq.com article), this is why you short a stock:
We recommend waiting until there is aggressive revenue recognition, weakening balance sheets, and deteriorating cash flow trends. It’s the flipside of value-with-catalyst, which is fundamental analysis of value combined with a catalyst for stock market buying to boost the price to realize that value.
As most Tesla Motors investors and followers know, the company’s cash flow is quite positive and revenue is on solid-footing with production capacity investments made in 2014, and the company’s estimate of 50,000 vehicles delivered in 2015. In 2014, Tesla will probably deliver just under 35,000 vehicles, a solid increase.
So there may be an opportunity to buy in the near-term for longs, as I feel the oil price “news” won’t really affect Tesla sales in 2015. One caveat, although, is to keep an eye on Model X news and possible struggles in hitting a 250 mile range for this coveted SUV. This could dampen the stock price if problems persist.
Tesla bear Michael Burry got blunt with his beliefs over the company’s valuation, which he called “ridiculously overvalued” in a newsletter to subscribers this past weekend.
“Tesla’s market capitalization is ridiculously overvalued today and has been for a good long time,” Burry, who was the inspiration for the movie The Big Short, and was portrayed by Christian Bale.
Burry went on to say, “As an aside, the Elon cult was all-in on electric cars until competition showed up, then all-in on autonomous driving until competition showed up, and now is all-in on robots — until competition shows up.”
Tesla bear Michael Burry ditches bet against $TSLA, says ‘media inflated’ the situation
For a long time, Burry has been skeptical of Tesla, its stock, and its CEO, Elon Musk, even placing a $530 million bet against shares several years ago. Eventually, Burry’s short position extended to other supporters of the company, including ARK Invest.
Tesla has long drawn skepticism from investors and more traditional analysts, who believe its valuation is overblown. However, the company is not traded as a traditional stock, something that other Wall Street firms have recognized.
While many believe the company has some serious pull as an automaker, an identity that helped it reach the valuation it has, Tesla has more than transformed into a robotics, AI, and self-driving play, pulling itself into the realm of some of the most recognizable stocks in tech.
Burry’s Scion Asset Management has put its money where its mouth is against Tesla stock on several occasions, but the firm has not yielded positive results, as shares have increased in value since 2020 by over 115 percent. The firm closed in May.
In 2020, it launched its short position, but by October 2021, it had ditched that position.
Tesla has had a tumultuous year on Wall Street, dipping significantly to around the $220 mark at one point. However, it rebounded significantly in September, climbing back up to the $400 region, as it currently trades at around $430.
It closed at $430.14 on Monday.
Investor's Corner
Mizuho keeps Tesla (TSLA) “Outperform” rating but lowers price target
As per the Mizuho analyst, upcoming changes to EV incentives in the U.S. and China could affect Tesla’s unit growth more than previously expected.
Mizuho analyst Vijay Rakesh lowered Tesla’s (NASDAQ:TSLA) price target to $475 from $485, citing potential 2026 EV subsidy cuts in the U.S. and China that could pressure deliveries. The firm maintained its Outperform rating for the electric vehicle maker, however.
As per the Mizuho analyst, upcoming changes to EV incentives in the U.S. and China could affect Tesla’s unit growth more than previously expected. The U.S. accounted for roughly 37% of Tesla’s third-quarter 2025 sales, while China represented about 34%, making both markets highly sensitive to policy shifts. Potential 50% cuts to Chinese subsidies and reduced U.S. incentives affected the firm’s outlook.
With those pressures factored in, the firm now expects Tesla to deliver 1.75 million vehicles in 2026 and 2 million in 2027, slightly below consensus estimates of 1.82 million and 2.15 million, respectively. The analyst was cautiously optimistic, as near-term pressure from subsidies is there, but the company’s long-term tech roadmap remains very compelling.
Despite the revised target, Mizuho remained optimistic on Tesla’s long-term technology roadmap. The firm highlighted three major growth drivers into 2027: the broader adoption of Full Self-Driving V14, the expansion of Tesla’s Robotaxi service, and the commercialization of Optimus, the company’s humanoid robot.
“We are lowering TSLA Ests/PT to $475 with Potential BEV headwinds in 2026E. We believe into 2026E, US (~37% of TSLA 3Q25 sales) EV subsidy cuts and China (34% of TSLA 3Q25 sales) potential 50% EV subsidy cuts could be a headwind to EV deliveries.
“We are now estimating TSLA deliveries for 2026/27E at 1.75M/2.00M (slightly below cons. 1.82M/2.15M). We see some LT drivers with FSD v14 adoption for autonomous, robotaxi launches, and humanoid robots into 2027 driving strength,” the analyst noted.
Tesla stock (NASDAQ: TSLA) has landed an elusive “must own” status from Wall Street firm Melius, according to a new note released early this week.
Analyst Rob Wertheimer said Tesla will lead the charge in world-changing tech, given the company’s focus on self-driving, autonomy, and Robotaxi. In a note to investors, Wertheimer said “the world is about to change, dramatically,” because of the advent of self-driving cars.
He looks at the industry and sees many potential players, but the firm says there will only be one true winner:
“Our point is not that Tesla is at risk, it’s that everybody else is.”
The major argument is that autonomy is nearing a tipping point where years of chipping away at the software and data needed to develop a sound, safe, and effective form of autonomous driving technology turn into an avalanche of progress.
Wertheimer believes autonomy is a $7 trillion sector,” and in the coming years, investors will see “hundreds of billions in value shift to Tesla.”
A lot of the major growth has to do with the all-too-common “butts in seats” strategy, as Wertheimer believes that only a fraction of people in the United States have ridden in a self-driving car. In Tesla’s regard, only “tens of thousands” have tried Tesla’s latest Full Self-Driving (Supervised) version, which is v14.
Tesla Full Self-Driving v14.2 – Full Review, the Good and the Bad
When it reaches a widespread rollout and more people are able to experience Tesla Full Self-Driving v14, he believes “it will shock most people.”
Citing things like Tesla’s massive data pool from its vehicles, as well as its shift to end-to-end neural nets in 2021 and 2022, as well as the upcoming AI5 chip, which will be put into a handful of vehicles next year, but will reach a wider rollout in 2027, Melius believes many investors are not aware of the pace of advancement in self-driving.
Tesla’s lead in its self-driving efforts is expanding, Wertheimer says. The company is making strategic choices on everything from hardware to software, manufacturing, and overall vehicle design. He says Tesla has left legacy automakers struggling to keep pace as they still rely on outdated architectures and fragmented supplier systems.
Tesla shares are up over 6 percent at 10:40 a.m. on the East Coast, trading at around $416.
Tesla Optimus shows off its newest capability as progress accelerates
Elon Musk and Tesla try to save legacy automakers from Déjà vu
