Connect with us
tesla tesla

News

Tesla range exaggeration lawsuit: a breakdown

Credit: Tesla

Published

on

Three Tesla owners have sued the automaker in a class action lawsuit that was filed on August 2, 2023, after a report from Reuters last week claims the company “exaggerates” its range ratings.

Teslarati examined the complaint, and we are here to give you a breakdown of what the suit says and what the three plaintiffs are suing Tesla for.

The Plaintiffs

Tesla is being sued by James Porter, Bryan Perez, and Dro Esraeili Estepanian, who state in their complaint against the automaker that their action “arises out of Tesla’s false advertising of its electric vehicles’ range, which Tesla grossly overvalued when selling the vehicles to consumers.”

According to the complaint, Porter owns a Model Y Performance and noticed a discrepancy in his vehicle’s range was compared to what it told him:

“After taking delivery of his Tesla vehicle in June 2022, Plaintiff Porter fully charged his vehicle to 100% battery charge and took a 2-hour trip to visit family, approximately 92 miles away. When he arrived at his destination, Plaintiff Porter noticed that the vehicle was left with approximately 40% charge.”

Perez owns a Model 3 Long Range, and the complaint states he had the same issue:

Advertisement
-

“After receiving his Tesla vehicle, Plaintiff Perez fully charged his vehicle to 100% battery charge and took an approximately 90-mile trip to visit his parents. After returning home from the approximately 180-mile round trip, he noticed that his vehicle showed that it had roughly 10-15% charge remaining.”

Estepanian also has a Model 3 Long Range, and the complaint describes a similar situation:

“Plaintiff Estepanian travels 140 to 150 miles round trip for his daily commute, and he routinely charges his vehicle to 90% battery charge (which equates to approximately 299 miles), per Tesla’s recommendation. Based on a 90% battery charge (and 299-mile starting range), he typically returns from his approximately 150-mile round trip each day and his Tesla vehicle’s screen displays that approximately 100 to 110 miles of range remain, which equates to roughly 33% battery charge remaining. Thus, Plaintiff Estepanian’s electric vehicle consistently loses approximately 189 miles of range during his daily commute—despite only driving approximately 140 to 150 miles round trip each day.”

The Plaintiffs’ Claims

The plaintiffs state that range is a key feature of electric vehicles and is “one of the most important features that consumers generally consider when purchasing an EV, because it correlates to the distance they can travel before needing to recharge the vehicle.”

Throughout the suit, the complaint shows images of Tesla’s website, highlighting range ratings and other “key features,” including top speed and acceleration.

They also include other pieces of evidence that seem to indicate Tesla has exaggerated range estimates.

Advertisement
-

One part of the complaint states:

“Tesla’s tactics to inflate the range estimates for its vehicles has continued. Recently, South Korean regulators fined Tesla for false advertising the ranges of its vehicles. Specifically, the Korea Fair Trade Commission found that Tesla exaggerated the “driving ranges of its cars on a single charge, their fuel cost-effectiveness compared to gasoline vehicles as well as the performance of its Superchargers.”

They also stated that other car companies to do not exaggerate range ratings, citing Recurrent’s testing of the Ford Mustang Mach-E, Chevrolet Bolt, and Hyundai Kona:

“Other electric vehicle manufacturers do not overestimate the range of their vehicles to the same extent. For example, Recurrent tested the Ford Mustang Mach-E, the Chevrolet Bolt, and the Hyundai Kona—all electric vehicles and direct competitors to Tesla model vehicles—and found their estimated ranges to be more accurate. In fact, the Hyundai Kona generally underestimated the range the vehicle could travel before requiring a recharge.”

Allegations in the Class Action Suit

The plaintiffs seek to represent anyone in California who purchased any Tesla vehicle and hope to solve questions including:

  • a. Whether Tesla model vehicles fail to deliver the advertised estimated vehicle range in normal driving conditions;
  • b. Whether Tesla exaggerated its advertised estimated vehicle ranges;
  • c. Whether Tesla knew that its advertised estimated vehicle ranges were exaggerated and could not be met under normal driving conditions;
  • d. When Tesla gained such knowledge;
  • e. Whether Tesla designed, manufacture, marketed, advertised, sold, or otherwise placed its model vehicles into the stream of commerce with such knowledge;
  • f. Whether Tesla intentionally concealed the fact that its advertised estimated vehicle ranges were exaggerated or otherwise could not be met under normal driving conditions;
  • g. Whether Tesla’s conduct to divert complaints from Class Members who voiced concerns over their Tesla model vehicle’s range violated the terms of Tesla’s warranties;
  • h. Whether Plaintiffs and Class Members were harmed by the fraud and deceptive practices alleged herein;
  • i. Whether Tesla was unjustly enriched by its deceptive practices; and
  • j. Whether Plaintiffs and the Class are entitled to equitable or injunctive relief

The case is 3:2023cv03878, Porter et al v. Tesla, Inc., and has been assigned to Judge Laurel Beeler.

I’d love to hear from you! If you have any comments, concerns, or questions, please email me at joey@teslarati.com. You can also reach me on Twitter @KlenderJoey, or if you have news tips, you can email us at tips@teslarati.com.

Advertisement
-

Joey has been a journalist covering electric mobility at TESLARATI since August 2019. In his spare time, Joey is playing golf, watching MMA, or cheering on any of his favorite sports teams, including the Baltimore Ravens and Orioles, Miami Heat, Washington Capitals, and Penn State Nittany Lions. You can get in touch with joey at joey@teslarati.com. He is also on X @KlenderJoey. If you're looking for great Tesla accessories, check out shop.teslarati.com

Advertisement
Comments

Elon Musk

Tesla may test customer-owned Robotaxis as early as next month, Musk says

Published

on

Credit: @AdanGuajardo/X

Elon Musk says that Tesla could test adding customer-owned vehicles to the Robotaxi platform as soon as December.

In a reply on X to an Austin-based Uber driver who uses a Model Y with Full Self-Driving and keeps only 49-63% of fares after the platform’s cut, Musk wrote:

“Coming soon. If things well, may start trials next month. Much better to manage a fleet of cars than have to drive just one car by yourself!”

Advertisement
-

The exchange highlights the appeal of passive income from an autonomous vehicle versus actively driving for rideshare platforms.

This potential December start is technically earlier than prior company guidance, but it also aligns with the currently-projected first delivery of the Tesla Cybercab, a vehicle that has no manual controls.

Nevertheless, Tesla planned to bring customer vehicles into the fleet later on. During Tesla’s Q3 earnings call, AI leadership had pointed to roughly the second quarter of 2027 for customer vehicles joining the network. Musk’s comment suggests an accelerated pilot, most likely beginning in Austin, where Tesla’s Robotaxi service has operated longest and where new features typically roll out first.

December is also the target month for the first customer deliveries of the Cybercab. In mid-November, Tesla began inviting select buyers to purchase the purpose-built, two-seat vehicle for personal use at $29,990 plus a required $299 monthly Autonomy Subscription, with estimated deliveries in Austin.

Tesla Cybercab goes on sale for $29,990, slated for December deliveries

Those initial private Cybercabs are restricted to personal use within existing Robotaxi zones and do not automatically include commercial network participation; the large majority of Cybercabs are expected to remain Tesla-owned fleet vehicles.

Advertisement
-

The coincidence of the two December milestones underscores Tesla’s parallel paths. Customer Model Ys already on the road with FSD hardware could rapidly enlarge the vehicle pool for unsupervised trials, while the Cybercab, which is void of a steering wheel or pedals and equipped with only dedicated Robotaxi hardware, arrives as a purpose-built platform.

Hardware differences, such as additional cameras or cleaning systems on company Robotaxis, may constrain which Model Ys are eligible at the outset. Regulatory approvals, insurance arrangements, and software readiness will also determine whether the “if things go well” condition is met.

For owners, successful trials would fulfill a vision Musk first sketched in Tesla’s 2016 Master Plan: vehicles that earn money while their owners sleep or work.

Combined with the arrival of privately owned Cybercabs in the same month, December could mark the transition from Tesla-controlled Robotaxi operations to a broader ecosystem in which both company fleets and customer vehicles contribute to the company’s autonomous ride-hailing platform, which continues expanding.

Continue Reading

Elon Musk

FAA turned down free Starlink offer before nationwide ground stop, Elon Musk says

Elon Musk says the FAA declined free Starlink terminals before last week’s nationwide ground stop.

Published

on

By

Elon Musk says the Federal Aviation Administration could have had Starlink backing up its air traffic communications for free, and he is pointing to last week’s nationwide ground stop as proof it was needed. “As I was saying … Free Starlinks for FAA were offered to Sec Duffy, but he said they were not needed. As it turns out, they were,” Musk wrote on X Monday.

Musk was quoting his own post from February 2025, when he wrote that “the ancient system that is rapidly declining in capability was made L3Harris,” while a newer replacement system from Verizon was “not yet operational.” The Department of Transportation has not responded publicly to Musk’s account of the offer.

The outage behind the post began at about 3:30 p.m. ET on Friday, November 13. According to the FAA’s own account, its legacy equipment became unstable when data began flooding its FAA Telecommunications Infrastructure network at a rate of 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds. The agency traced the flood to two locations, a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where L3Harris had been installing a new router.

Instability spread across 17 of the FAA’s 22 Air Route Traffic Control Centers. The agency grounded departures nationwide while about 3,500 aircraft already in the air landed safely, and lifted the stop at 8:15 p.m. ET. Operators canceled roughly 12,462 flights that day, though the FAA notes not all of those were directly caused by the ground stop. L3Harris blocked the two sites to stabilize the network, and the FAA disabled the same router function on about 60 similar units. Officials found no sign of a cyberattack.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has blamed prior administrations and dated systems, and has called on Congress to fund a $50 billion overhaul of the system.

Musk’s history with the FAA network goes back to early 2025, when he was leading the Department of Government Efficiency. He claimed on X that the system was failing and putting air travelers at risk, initially blaming Verizon before correcting himself to name L3Harris. The FAA confirmed at the time it was testing Starlink terminals, one at its Atlantic City, New Jersey facility and two at “non-safety critical sites” in Alaska. SpaceX said it was providing the kits at no cost and had no intent to take over any existing FAA contract.

Advertisement
-

Duffy described Starlink then as “part of a solution” rather than a replacement. By July 2025, the FAA told lawmakers it was not considering replacing its L3Harris and Verizon telecommunications contracts with Starlink.

Whether Starlink would have prevented Friday’s disruption is not clear. The FAA described a fault inside its terrestrial network rather than a loss of connectivity, and Musk did not explain how satellite links would have been used. His post does put SpaceX back in the conversation as Washington debates how to pay for the next air traffic control system. SpaceX already supplies Starlink to commercial airlines for inflight connectivity, and United’s rollout required FAA certification for each aircraft type.

Continue Reading

News

Tesla makes $3.3 billion Cybercab bet at Giga Berlin

Published

on

Credit: Tesla

It is no secret Tesla is prioritizing Cybercab production as it plans to launch a fleet of fully autonomous vehicles without steering wheels or pedals across the world. Today, it made a €3 billion bet to do so in Europe.

Tesla announced on November 16, that it will invest €3 billion (approximately $3.3 billion) to expand its Gigafactory in Grünheide near Berlin, its only vehicle manufacturing site in Europe.

The investment will fund a major new production building—roughly twice the size of the existing main hall—and supporting infrastructure, including an additional wastewater treatment plant. The new facility is designed to produce up to one million Cybercabs annually once fully scaled, alongside continued Model Y output.

Advertisement
-

Tesla plans to file the building permit application before the end of 2026, according to Tagesspiegel, drawing on a broader expansion application submitted in 2023 that targets one million vehicles per year overall. Construction is scheduled to begin in the first half of 2027, with Cybercab production starting in 2029.

The company is already recruiting several hundred workers for construction and production planning. The site currently employs about 12,600 people after recent hiring of roughly 2,000, and it is ramping Model Y production toward 7,500 vehicles per week (around 375,000 annually).

This vehicle expansion comes just days after plant manager André Thierig indicated at the Automobilwoche Congress on November 11 that full battery cell production at Grünheide is on track for mid-2027.

The factory already produces electrodes, which are currently shipped to Texas for cell assembly and returned; the goal is to complete 4680-format cells on site using Tesla’s dry-electrode process, targeting up to 18 GWh annually.

The cumulative investment in the cell operation approaches €1 billion and is expected to create more than 1,500 jobs. Once operational, Giga Berlin would become the first plant in Europe to produce everything from battery cells to finished vehicles under one roof, raising the European content of its Model Ys to roughly 90 percent.

For Tesla’s German operations, the twin moves deepen vertical integration and reduce dependence on transatlantic and Chinese supply chains.

Advertisement
-

They also contrast sharply with the broader German automotive industry, which faces high costs, weak demand, and job cuts; Brandenburg officials have welcomed the investment as a significant economic boost that creates hundreds of new positions and strengthens the region as a manufacturing hub.

Tesla’s expansion advances its strategic pivot toward autonomy and robotaxis. The Cybercab is intended to become a high-volume product; adding major European capacity diversifies production beyond the United States and supports Elon Musk’s vision of autonomous vehicles comprising the majority of Tesla’s future output.

Combined with localized 4680 cell production, the plans position Giga Berlin as a more self-sufficient, technologically advanced European base, enhancing competitiveness as regulatory and market conditions favor higher local content.

Continue Reading