Connect with us

News

SpaceX’s path to refueling Starships in space is clearer than it seems

Published

on

Perhaps the single biggest mystery of SpaceX’s Starship program is how exactly the company plans to refuel the largest spacecraft ever built after they reach orbit.

First revealed in September 2016 as the Interplanetary Transport System (ITS), SpaceX has radically redesigned its next-generation rocket several times over the last half-decade. Several crucial aspects have nevertheless persisted. Five years later, Starship (formerly ITS and BFR) is still a two-stage rocket powered by Raptor engines that burn a fuel-rich mixture of liquid methane (LCH4) and liquid oxygen (LOx). Despite being significantly scaled back from ITS, Starship will be about the same height (120 m or 390 ft) and is still on track to be the tallest, heaviest, and most powerful rocket ever launched by a large margin.

Building off of years of growing expertise from dozens of Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy launches, the most important fundamental design goal of Starship is full and rapid reusability – propellant being the only thing intentionally ‘expended’ during launches. However, like BFR and ITS before it, the overarching purpose of Starship is to support SpaceX’s founding goal of making humanity multiplanetary and building a self-sustaining city on Mars. For Starship to have even a chance of accomplishing that monumental feat, SpaceX will not only have to build the most easily and rapidly reusable rocket and spacecraft in history, but it will also have to master orbital refueling.

The reuse/refuel equation

In the context of SpaceX’s goals of expanding humanity to Mars, a mastery of reusability and orbital refueling are mutually inclusive. Without both, neither alone will enable the creation of a sustainable city on Mars. A Starship launch system that can be fully reused on a weekly or even daily basis but can’t be rapidly and easily refueled in space simply doesn’t have the performance needed to affordably build, supply, and populate a city on another planet (or Moon). A Starship launch system that can be easily refueled but is not rapidly and fully reusable could allow for some degree of interplanetary transport and the creation of a minimal human outpost on Mars, but it would probably be one or two magnitudes more difficult, risky, and expensive to operate and would require a huge fleet of ships and boosters from the start.

The question of how SpaceX will make Starship the world’s most rapidly, fully, and cheaply reusable rocket is a hard one, but it’s not all that difficult to extrapolate from where the company is today. Currently, the turnaround record (time between two flights) for Falcon boosters is two launches in less than four weeks (27 days). SpaceX’s orbital-class reuse is also making strides and the company recently flew the same orbital Crew Dragon capsule twice in just 137 days (less than five months) – fast approaching turnarounds similar to NASA’s Space Shuttle average, the only other reusable orbital spacecraft in history.

SpaceX’s current fleet of four reusable Dragon spacecraft. (NASA/Mike Hopkins/ESA/Thomas Pesquet)
Pictured here during its last launch, Falcon 9 B1060 owns SpaceX’s turnaround record of just 27 days and has completed eight orbital-class launches in 12 months, averaging one flight every ~45 days – an average turnaround time that’s better than the Space Shuttle’s all-time record. (SpaceX)

While Dragon and Falcon 9 are far smaller than Starship and Super Heavy, Dragon is only partially reusable and requires significant refurbishment after recovery and Falcon 9 boosters are fairly complex. Starship, on the other hand, should effectively serve as a fully reusable all-in-one Falcon upper stage, Dragon capsule, Dragon trunk, and fairing, making it far more complex but potentially far more reusable. To an extent, Super Heavy should also be mechanically simpler than Falcon boosters (no deployable legs or fins; no structural composite-metal joints; no dedicated maneuvering thrusters) and its clean-burning Raptor engines should be easier to reuse than Falcon’s Merlins. Put simply, there are precedents set and evidence provided by Falcon rockets and NASA’s Space Shuttle that suggest SpaceX will be able to solve the reusability half of the equation.

What about refueling?

The other half of that equation, however, could not be more different. The sum total of SpaceX’s official discussions of orbital refueling can be summed up in a sentence included verbatim in CEO Elon Musk’s 2017, 2018, and 2019 Starship presentations: “propellant settled by milli G acceleration using control thrusters.”

Advertisement
-
This phrase first appeared in 2017 (PDF; page 16). (SpaceX)

On the face of it, that simple phrase doesn’t reveal much. However, with a few grains of salt, hints from what the company’s CEO has and hasn’t said, and context from the history of research into orbital propellant transfer, it’s possible to paint a fairly detailed picture of the exact mechanisms SpaceX will likely use to refill Starships in space. The cornerstone, somewhat ironically, is a 2006 paper – written by seven Lockheed Martin employees and a NASA engineer – titled “Settled Cryogenic Propellant Transfer.” Aside from the obvious corollaries just from the title alone, the paper focuses on what the authors argue is the simplest possible route to large-scale orbital propellant transfer.

In orbit, under microgravity conditions, the propellant inside a spacecraft’s tanks is effectively detached from the structure. If a spacecraft applies thrust, that propellant will stay still until it splashes against its tank walls – the most basic Newtonian principle that objects at rest tend to stay at rest. If, say, a spacecraft thrusts in one direction and opens a hatch or valve on the tank in the opposite direction of that thrust, the propellant inside it – attempting to stay at rest – will naturally escape out of that opening. Thus, if a spacecraft in need of fuel docks with a tanker, their tanks are connected and opened, and the tanker attempts to accelerate away from the receiving ship, the propellant in the tanker’s tanks will effectively be pushed into the second ship as it tries to stay at rest.

The principles behind such a ‘settled propellant transfer’ are fairly simple and intuitive. The crucial question is how much acceleration the process requires and how expensive that continuous acceleration ends up being. According to Kutter et al’s 2006 paper, the answer is surprising: assuming a 100 metric ton (~220,000 lb) spacecraft pair accelerates at 0.0001G (one ten-thousandth of Earth gravity) to transfer propellant, they would need to consume just 45 kg (100 lb) of hydrogen and oxygen propellant per hour to maintain that acceleration.

Two possible Starship orientations for propellant transfer. (SpaceX)

In the most extreme hypothetical refueling scenario (i.e. a completely full tanker refueling a ship with a full cargo bay), two docked Starships would weigh closer to 1600 tons (~3.5M lb) and the “Milli G” acceleration SpaceX has repeatedly mentioned in presentation slides would be ten times greater than the maximum acceleration analyzed by Kutter et al. Still, according to their paper, that propellant cost scales linearly both with the required acceleration and with the mass of the system. Roughly speaking, using the same assumptions, that means that the thrusting Starship would theoretically consume just over 7 tons (half a percent) of its methane and oxygen propellant per hour to maintain milli-G acceleration.

With large enough pipes (on the order of 20-50 cm or 8-20 in) connecting each Starship’s tanks, SpaceX should have no trouble transferring 1000+ tons of propellant in a handful of hours. Ultimately, that means that settled propellant transfer even at the scale of Starship should incur a performance ‘tax’ of no more than 20-50 tons of propellant per refueling. All transfers leading up to the worst-case 1600-ton scenario should also be substantially more efficient. Overall, that means that fully refueling an orbiting Starship or depot with ~1200 tons of propellant – requiring anywhere from 8 to 14+ tanker launches – should be surprisingly efficient, with perhaps 80% or more of the propellant launched remaining usable by the end of the process.

On Super Heavy B4, SpaceX has installed what amount to nozzles over the booster’s main oxygen tank vents to vector and maximize the thrust they produce. (NASASpaceflight – bocachicagal)

A step further, Kutter et al note the amount of acceleration required is so small that a hypothetical spacecraft could potentially use ullage gas vents to achieve it, meaning that custom-designed settling thrusters might not even be needed. Coincidentally or not, SpaceX (or CEO Elon Musk) has recently decided to use strategically located ullage vents to replace purpose-built maneuvering thrusters on Starship’s Super Heavy booster. If SpaceX adds similar capabilities to Starship, it’s quite possible that the combination of cryogenic propellant naturally boiling into gas as it warms and the ullage vents used to relieve that added pressure could produce enough thrust to transfer large volumes of propellant.

Last but not least, writing more than a decade and a half ago, the only technological barrier Kutter et al could foresee to large-scale settled propellant transfer wasn’t even related to refueling but, rather, to the ability to autonomously rendezvous and dock in orbit. In 2006, while Russia was already routinely using autonomous docking and rendezvous technology on its Soyuz and Progress spacecraft, the US had never demonstrated the technology on its own. Jump to today and SpaceX Dragon spacecraft have autonomously rendezvoused with the International Space Station twenty seven times in nine years and completed ten autonomous dockings – all without issue – since 2019.

SpaceX has already developed and thoroughly tested hot-gas Raptor-derived maneuvering thrusters that could be fairly easily added to Starship to boost the efficiency of settled propellant transfer at the cost of added weight and complexity. (NASASpaceflight – bocachicagal)

Even though SpaceX and its executives have never detailed their approach to refueling (or refilling, per Musk’s preferred term) Starships in space, there is a clear path established by decades of NASA and industry research. What little evidence is available suggests that that path is the same one SpaceX has chosen to travel. Ultimately, the key takeaway from that research and SpaceX’s apparent use of it should be this: while a relatively inefficient process, SpaceX has effectively already solved the last remaining technical hurdle for settled propellant transfer and should be able to easily refuel Starships in orbit with little to no major development required.

There’s a good chance that minor to moderate problems will be discovered and need to be solved once SpaceX begins to test refueling in orbit but crucially, there are no obvious showstoppers standing between SpaceX and the start of those flight tests. Aside from the obvious (preparing a new rocket for its first flight tests), the only major refueling problem SpaceX arguably needs to solve is the umbilical ports and docking mechanisms that will enable propellant transfer. SpaceX will also need to settle on a location for those ports/mechanisms and decide whether to implement ullage vent ‘thrusters’, cold gas thrusters like those on Falcon and current Starship prototypes, or more efficient hot-gas thrusters derived from Raptors. At the end of the day, though, those are all solved problems and just a matter of complex but routine systems engineering that SpaceX is an expert at.

Advertisement
-

Eric Ralph is Teslarati's senior spaceflight reporter and has been covering the industry in some capacity for almost half a decade, largely spurred in 2016 by a trip to Mexico to watch Elon Musk reveal SpaceX's plans for Mars in person. Aside from spreading interest and excitement about spaceflight far and wide, his primary goal is to cover humanity's ongoing efforts to expand beyond Earth to the Moon, Mars, and elsewhere.

Advertisement
Comments

News

Tesla just doubled its Miami Robotaxi geofence

Published

on

Credit: Tesla

Tesla just doubled the serviceable area that its Robotaxi platform can travel in Miami, Florida.

On November 16, Tesla announced a major expansion of its Miami service area with a message stating that it would now service substantially more of the city. A new map shows the new service area, which is roughly double the initial geofence, including key urban districts into Robotaxi for the first time.

Tesla first launched unsupervised Robotaxi rides in Miami on July 3, making it the company’s initial market outside of Texas and California. The original geofence covered a very limited portion of the western Miami-Dade area, including West Miami, Doral, Sweetwater, and Miami International Airport. It was roughly 25 square miles, before a small expansion put it at about 31.

Now, Downtown Miami, the popular Brickell neighborhood, and Miami Beach, which were deliberately left outside the boundary initially, now are included in operations. Riders can now hail Model Y vehicles booked through the Tesla Robotaxi app and have run 24 hours a day since mid-November.

The map now looks to be about 59 square miles, a roughly 92 percent increase. The new eastern edge of the geofence now includes Downtown, Bickell, Wynwood, Little Havana, and the Biscayne Bay waterfront, nailing down a lot of typical tourist locations for Miami visitors. Additionally, the new geofence also extends North, reaching Hialeah, and adding coverage closer to the airport corridor.

At its widest, the zone now stretches roughly 11 miles from west to east. Miami Beach remains outside the service area, though Elon Musk previously indicated beach coverage was “coming soon” after Florida Governor Ron DeSantis publicly called for it.

Relative to Tesla’s other markets, Miami’s roughly 59-square-mile zone is now larger than Orlando (about 26 square miles) and Tampa (about 24 square miles) combined.

It remains smaller than Texas hubs such as Austin (around 443 square miles), San Antonio (about 275), Houston (about 254), and Fort Worth (about 143), but the rapid growth brings it closer to competitor Waymo’s approximately 60-square-mile Miami footprint, which already includes beach areas.

For Miami residents and visitors, the expansion makes driverless rides practical for trips into the city’s densest commercial and residential core, offering a new option amid heavy traffic and limited parking.

For Tesla, covering higher-demand downtown corridors should increase ride volume, generate more real-world autonomy data, and strengthen its competitive position as it scales the Robotaxi network toward broader profitability and eventual Cybercab deployment. The overnight growth also signals accelerating operational confidence less than five months after the city’s launch.

Continue Reading

Cybertruck

Tesla tuner pleading to save Cybertruck also wants to build CyberSUV

Published

on

Credit: Unplugged Performance

Tesla tuner Unplugged Performance, the company pleading to save the Cybertruck, detailed in a new phase of its plan to rescue manufacturing lines from Gigafactory Texas that it would also build a three-row CyberSUV.

UP has already navigated a lot of the difficult thought work, including how it will woo Tesla to turn over the all-electric pickup’s production lines at no cost or risk to them. Tesla has signaled it will wind down Cybertruck output at Gigafactory Texas sometime around the middle of next year.

Tesla upfitter offers to keep Cybertruck alive

Unplugged, the Hawthorne-based aftermarket specialist that has tuned Teslas since 2013, first floated an open offer on November 10 and followed with a more specific “Phase 3” outline on November 15. Under the structure, outside investors would fund the new company.

The line would leave Giga Texas on Tesla’s schedule, supplier contracts would transfer, and Unplugged would hire its own staff, drawing from interested Tesla alumni, without pulling current Tesla employees or engineering resources.

Tesla would retain intellectual-property ownership, final say on specifications and brand, a quality veto, and an option to reclaim the line. In return, Tesla would collect a license fee on every vehicle plus margin on parts it continues to supply, Full Self-Driving and Robotaxi revenue, and a no-cost equity stake in the new entity.

If Unplugged cannot meet demand or capital targets Tesla sets, it would withdraw.

UP looked at the overwhelming demand for a full-size SUV, something that Tesla has had a lot of demand for but has not developed internally. A poll put out by the tuner that surveyed 892 responses showed 82 percent of voters favored a CyberSUV. There is a substantially deeper market for three-row SUVs priced above $80,000 compared to pickups.

Not to mention, the new body tooling plus limiting other changes from the Cybertruck line would enable the company to use the existing platform to produce an all-terrain family vehicle while continuing to produce Cybertruck builds at a modest incremental cost.

Tesla has already shown interest in a CyberSUV, as it hid Cybertruck-inspired clay models of what appeared to be a full-size SUV in a video last year:

Tesla appears to be mulling a Cyber SUV design

The proposal from UP also contemplates multiple configurations that would enable owners to utilize a full-fledged Robotaxi in the form of a CyberSUV, aiming to build one with conventional controls for private buyers while a no-wheel/pedal version would be available for the Robotaxi fleet.

Tesla has made it clear that its manufacturing space and cell capacity is set aside for Cybercab, but UP already has soft commitments from a conglomeration of investors, but it all hinges on Tesla’s willingness to engage.

Continue Reading

Elon Musk

Your Tesla could be in the Robotaxi fleet next month, Elon Musk claims

Published

on

Credit: @AdanGuajardo/X

Elon Musk says that Tesla could test adding customer-owned vehicles to the Robotaxi platform as soon as December.

In a reply on X to an Austin-based Uber driver who uses a Model Y with Full Self-Driving and keeps only 49-63% of fares after the platform’s cut, Musk wrote:

“Coming soon. If things well, may start trials next month. Much better to manage a fleet of cars than have to drive just one car by yourself!”

The exchange highlights the appeal of passive income from an autonomous vehicle versus actively driving for rideshare platforms.

This potential December start is technically earlier than prior company guidance, but it also aligns with the currently-projected first delivery of the Tesla Cybercab, a vehicle that has no manual controls.

Nevertheless, Tesla planned to bring customer vehicles into the fleet later on. During Tesla’s Q3 earnings call, AI leadership had pointed to roughly the second quarter of 2027 for customer vehicles joining the network. Musk’s comment suggests an accelerated pilot, most likely beginning in Austin, where Tesla’s Robotaxi service has operated longest and where new features typically roll out first.

December is also the target month for the first customer deliveries of the Cybercab. In mid-November, Tesla began inviting select buyers to purchase the purpose-built, two-seat vehicle for personal use at $29,990 plus a required $299 monthly Autonomy Subscription, with estimated deliveries in Austin.

Tesla Cybercab goes on sale for $29,990, slated for December deliveries

Those initial private Cybercabs are restricted to personal use within existing Robotaxi zones and do not automatically include commercial network participation; the large majority of Cybercabs are expected to remain Tesla-owned fleet vehicles.

The coincidence of the two December milestones underscores Tesla’s parallel paths. Customer Model Ys already on the road with FSD hardware could rapidly enlarge the vehicle pool for unsupervised trials, while the Cybercab, which is void of a steering wheel or pedals and equipped with only dedicated Robotaxi hardware, arrives as a purpose-built platform.

Hardware differences, such as additional cameras or cleaning systems on company Robotaxis, may constrain which Model Ys are eligible at the outset. Regulatory approvals, insurance arrangements, and software readiness will also determine whether the “if things go well” condition is met.

For owners, successful trials would fulfill a vision Musk first sketched in Tesla’s 2016 Master Plan: vehicles that earn money while their owners sleep or work.

Combined with the arrival of privately owned Cybercabs in the same month, December could mark the transition from Tesla-controlled Robotaxi operations to a broader ecosystem in which both company fleets and customer vehicles contribute to the company’s autonomous ride-hailing platform, which continues expanding.

Continue Reading