Connect with us

News

Tesla not violating labor laws at Giga Berlin: State Parliament

Credit: @gigafactory_4/Twitter

Published

on

Update: The Parliament members read a report from the Occupational Health and Safety Authority, which visits the Giga Berlin site every week. There was no exceedance of 8 hours of working time found by the Authority, nor were there any violations of COVID-19 protocols, via Claus Ableiter.

Tesla has been found not to be violating labor laws at its German Gigafactory, better known as Giga Berlin, State Parliament members say. After a meeting on Tuesday, which had several members of the Parliament speak regarding their findings at the Giga Berlin site, Tesla is not violating any labor laws that protect employees and workers from being subjected to unfair practices.

In a report earlier this week, Business Insider stated that the State Office for Occupational Safety, along with an agency required to investigate labor law violation claims, was told to investigate the possibility of employees at the site being overworked in unfair conditions and being paid below-par wages.

“The assessment is that the overall work situation is great.” -Parliament Member Ernst-Friedrich Pernack

The claims followed more negative reports regarding Tesla’s first European Gigafactory from earlier this week. German media site Automobilwoche claimed that a member of Elon Musk’s inner circle had admitted the Giga Berlin factory wouldn’t begin producing cars until January 2022. Jörg Steinbach, the Economic Minister for Brandenburg, the state where the site is located, disputed these claims and told Teslarati that he still anticipates Tesla to begin initial production in “late-Summer or early-Autumn.”

However, at the meeting with the Parliament in Grünheide, the municipality where the factory is located, members stated that there were no findings or “serious deficiencies” in Tesla’s work conditions. After visits and some investigations this week, members of the Parliament who were tasked with discussing the findings said, “So far, we have not received any information that it could be such unworthy conditions as they are in the press.”

Advertisement

The Tweet above says (via Google Translate):

“There have been reports of long hours and unworthy working conditions at Tesla’s construction site in #Grünheide. In a meeting of the state parliament today, the responsible authorities reported and so far found no serious deficiencies.”

“The assessment is that the overall work situation is great,” one Parliament member, Ernst-Friedrich Pernack, who spoke in great lengths about the situation, said. “Overall, worker protection is very satisfactory in relation to other large construction sites few issues & accidents not over average,” he added.

Advertisement

According to Pernack, a total of 17 visits to the Giga Berlin property have been made so far in 2021 alone, accounting for around one visit per week so far. There have been no concerns raised by the Parliament, nor by the Construction Trade Association, who also conducts the weekly inspections with the Parliament members. There are still ongoing investigations with work hours, and some other issues, Pernack stated.

EXCLUSIVE: Tesla Giga Berlin isn’t facing a 6-month delay: German Minister

The comments made regarding Tesla’s working conditions by the Parliament indicate that there are no violations of labor laws at the German plant. Tesla said in its recent Q1 2021 Update Letter that “production and deliveries remain on track for late 2021.”

The portion of the Parliament Meeting where Giga Berlin’s labor conditions are discussed is available below thanks to GrünheideForFuture.

Advertisement

Joey has been a journalist covering electric mobility at TESLARATI since August 2019. In his spare time, Joey is playing golf, watching MMA, or cheering on any of his favorite sports teams, including the Baltimore Ravens and Orioles, Miami Heat, Washington Capitals, and Penn State Nittany Lions. You can get in touch with joey at joey@teslarati.com. He is also on X @KlenderJoey. If you're looking for great Tesla accessories, check out shop.teslarati.com

Comments

News

Tesla FSD rivalry heats up in China as Zeekr launches free version

Zeekr’s new hands-on, lidar-based system is set to challenge Tesla FSD in China. Will “free” give Zeekr an edge? 

Published

on

tesla-vs-zeeker-driver-assist-system
(Credit: Zeekr)

Tesla FSD rivalry is heating up in China as another competitor, Zeekr, launches a free version of its advanced driver-assistance system.

Zeekr’s driver-assist system will enable car owners to drive nearly autonomously from one location to a pre-set destination. Drivers are required to keep their hands on the steering wheel at all times during the drive. Zeekr’s diver-assistance system is in the process of retrieving regulatory approval in China. The Chinese company plans to release the free version to a pilot test group before its full launch to the public in April.

“Right now, in this period of development, I think subscriptions aren’t that meaningful,” Zeekr CEO Andy An told CNBC.

He noted that the intense competition in the driver-assistance and autonomous driving space means Zeekr must become a top player. “So we need to bear some cost,” he added.

Zeekr’s driver-assistance system uses two Nvidia Orin X chipsets and one lidar to help vehicles navigate. However, the company already has plans to improve its system in the future with Nvidia’s Thor automotive chip, one long-range lidar, and four short-range lidar units. Although Zeekr’s CEO noted that the company’s cars sold abroad will not use Nvidia chips for now due to differences in regulations and local market demand.

Advertisement

“Using lidar may increase cost, but this reflects how much we value safety,” commented An.

Zeekr’s use of lidar already sets it apart from Tesla’s Full Self-Driving. Tesla is considered a leading company in the driver-assist and autonomous driving space. The American-based company’s FSD does not use lidar and does not rely on pre-set destinations. Tesla FSD is currently in the middle of the regulation process in China and Europe.

Tesla China recently rolled out a promotion for FSD, as it believes customers just need to try it to appreciate its capabilities. Tesla China is offering new customers in China one free month of FSD between March 17 and April 16, 2025. Baidu engineers are helping with Tesla FSD improvements in China.

Continue Reading

News

RBC cuts Tesla’s price target to $320, with a potential upside of 34%

RBC slashes its TSLA price target from $440 to $320 but still sees a potential 34% upside!

Published

on

Credit: Jim Koehler | X

RBC Capital Markets analyst Tom Narayan cut Tesla’s price target from $440 to $320. RBC is the latest firm to lower its Tesla price target. However, the RBC analyst’s new TSLA price target still represents a potential upside of 34%.

Narayan follows other TSLA analysts who have cut their price targets for the company. Goldman Sachs also lowered its Telsa price target to $320 from $345. Last week, Wells Fargo slashed its TSLA price target to $130 from $135.

Narayan kept an “Outperform” rating on Tesla’s shares. His latest Tesla price target is based on lowered expectations around the company’s Full Self-Driving (FSD) capabilities. “We now assume Tesla FSD pricing drops to $50/month in 2026 from $100/month today,” noted the RBC analyst.

Narayan emphasized that Tesla is facing pressure from competition in markets abroad, specifically in China. “While we do think it unwise to extrapolate too much from car demand dynamics, Tesla is losing market share in Europe and China.

Advertisement

“In China, in particular, competition is intensifying. Further, on robotaxis, we think it likely that domestic OEMs [original equipment manufacturers] will dominate the market. As a result, we now lower our market share assumption to 10% from 20% in both markets,” he said.

Narayan stands in stark contrast to other analysts who have mostly based their TSLA price target cuts on its lower-than-expected Q1 2025 delivery numbers. The RBC analyst believes delivery fears have been “overblown.”

“Although sales fell sharply in Europe (45% in January) and China (60% in January and 21% in February), these regions represent a small portion of Tesla’s total sales compared to their annual figures (311k in Europe and 683k in China for ’24). Tesla’s U.S. sales, on the other hand, saw modest increases,” he noted.

The majority of analysts see Tesla’s Full Self-Driving as a positive driving force in Tesla stock. Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas, for example, predicts Tesla will rebound over 90% within the next year. Jonas lists Tesla’s FSD Unsupervised use in paid rideshare services in Texas as one of the catalysts for TSLA stocks to rise back up.

Continue Reading

News

Tesla is NOT done in Germany–exact same poll debunks its own “94% won’t buy Tesla” narrative

As of writing, 307,119 readers, or 69.9% of the study’s overall respondents, stated that they would still buy a Tesla.

Published

on

Credit: Romain Hedouin/X

As it turns out, news of Tesla’s demand death in Germany have been widely exaggerated. This is highlighted by the same poll that was used to frame the narrative that 94% of car buyers will not buy a Tesla in Germany.

So no, Tesla is not done in Germany. Nowhere close.

The Survey and the Reports

A look at the Tesla news cycle over the past few days would show that one of the biggest stories about the electric vehicle maker involved the results of a survey from German publication t-online. As per the reports, a survey of over 100,000 t-online readers has shown that 94% were not willing to buy a Tesla, and only a minuscule 3% were still willing to consider a vehicle from the American EV maker. 

t-online’s report on its survey, as well as articles that cited the study, related the alleged drop in Tesla interest in Germany to Elon Musk’s conservative politics. However, the survey itself received polarizing reactions among social media users since its respondents were self-selected. The poll also seemed open to everyone globally, so its results may not have been the most accurate.

These concerns, of course, were largely ignored and dismissed as the complaints of Tesla “cult” members or “stans,” as critics stated on social media. Unfortunately for Elon Musk/Tesla critics, it appears that t-online‘s Tesla poll is not done telling its story just yet.

Advertisement

Ongoing Survey, Drastically Different Results

While t-online published its article about Tesla’s alleged decline in Germany after the study passed 100,000 responses, the survey itself was actually left open. Thus, despite articles stating that Tesla is done in Germany already spreading online, t-online’s survey was still gathering data from respondents. Interestingly enough, the survey started showing a drastically different narrative once it started getting more respondents.

As of writing, a total of 439,111 respondents have participated in t-online’s Tesla survey. As of writing, 307,119 readers, or 69.9% of the study’s overall respondents, stated that they would still buy a Tesla. A total of 128,643 readers, or 29.3% of the study’s respondents, stated that they would “absolutely no way” consider a Tesla. A total of 3,296 t-online readers, or 0.8% of the survey’s current respondents, stated that they “do not know” if they would like to buy a Tesla.

Keeping Things in Perspective

While one could argue that the current findings of the survey are probably astroturfed by Tesla “stans” or “cult” members, the fact remains that the poll itself was flawed to begin with. Its self-selected respondents could have been affected by bias, and the fact that it seemed open to all users across the globe suggests that the study may not have accurately represented Germany’s car buying public at all.

With this in mind, it would be unreasonable to argue that t-online‘s poll was completely accurate up to its first 100,000 respondents but inaccurate when more respondents answered the survey. The reports that emerged from the first 100,000 respondents of the poll concluded that Tesla was finished in Germany. Following the same logic, one could argue that such reports were premature, and based on updated data from the same survey, Tesla still enjoys majority support in Germany.

Continue Reading

Trending