Connect with us

News

SpaceX nears big US govt. missions as ULA handwaves about risks of competition

Falcon 9 B1045 rolls out to Pad 40 ahead of its first launch in April 2018. (NASA/SpaceX)

Published

on

Speaking at the 2018 Von Braun Symposium in Huntsville, Alabama, ULA COO John Elbon expressed worries that the US National Security Space (NSS) apparatus could be put at significant risk if it comes to rely too heavily on the commercial launch industry to assure access to space.

Given that the US military’s launch capabilities rest solely on SpaceX and ULA and will remain that way for at least three more years, Elbon’s comment was effectively an odd barb tossed in the direction of SpaceX and – to a lesser extent – Blue Origin, two disruptive and commercially-oriented launch providers.

Reading between the lines

For the most part, Elbon’s brief presentation centered around a reasonable discussion of ULA’s track record and future vehicle development, emphasizing the respectable reliability of its current Atlas V and Delta IV rockets and the ‘heritage’ they share with ULA’s next-generation Vulcan vehicle. However, the COO twice brought up an intriguing concern that the US military launch apparatus could suffer if it ends up relying too heavily on ‘commercially-sustained’ launch vehicles like Falcon 9/Heavy or New Glenn.

To provide historical context and evidence favorable to his position, Elbon brought up a now-obscure event in the history of the launch industry, where – 20 years ago – companies Lockheed Martin and Boeing reportedly “set out to develop … Atlas V and Delta IV” primarily to support the launch of several large satellite constellations. The reality and causes of the US launch industry’s instability in the late ’90s and early ’00s is almost indistinguishable from this narrative, however.

Despite the many veils of aerospace and military secrecy surrounding the events that occurred afterward, the facts show that – in 1999 – Boeing (per acquisition of McDonnell Douglas) and Lockheed Martin (LM) both received awards of $500M to develop the Delta IV and Atlas V rockets, and the military further committed to buying a full 28 launches for $2B between 2002 and 2006. Combined, the US military effectively placed $3B ($4.5B in 2018 dollars) on the table for its Evolved Expendable Launch Vehicle (EELV) program with the goal of ensuring uninterrupted access to space for national security purposes.

Advertisement
-

Rocketing into corporate espionage

“The robust commercial market forecast led the Air Force to reconsider its acquisition strategy.  The EELV acquisition strategy changed from a planned down-select to a single contractor and a standard Air Force development program [where the USAF funds vehicle development in its entirety] to a dual commercialized approach that leveraged commercial market share and contractor investment.” – USAF EELV Fact Sheet, March 2017

The above quote demonstrates that there is at least an inkling of truth in Elbon’s spin. However, perhaps the single biggest reason that the EELV program and its two awardees stumbled was gross, inexcusable conduct on the part of Boeing. In essence, the company’s space executives conspired to use corporate espionage to gain an upper-hand over Lockheed Martin, knowledge which ultimately allowed Boeing to severely low-ball the prices of its Delta IV rocket, securing 19 of 28 available USAF launch contracts.

Ultimately, Lockheed Martin caught wind of Boeing’s suspect behavior and filed a lawsuit that began several years of USAF investigations and highly unpleasant revelations, while Boeing also had at least 10 future launch contracts withdrawn to the tune of ~$1B (1999). USAF investigations discovered that Boeing had lied extensively to the Air Force for more than four years – the actual volume of information stolen would balloon wildly from Boeing’s initial reports of “seven pages of harmless data” to 10+ boxes containing more than 42,000 pages of extremely detailed technical and proprietary information about Lockheed Martin’s Atlas V rocket proposal.

“If you rewind the clock 20 years, there were folks on a panel like this having dialogue about commercial launch, and there were envisioned several constellations that were going to require significant commercial launch. Lockheed Martin and Boeing set out to develop launch vehicles that were focused on that very robust commercial market – in the case of McDonald Douglas at the time, which later became Boeing, the factory in Decatur was…sized to crank out 40 [rocket boosters] a year, a couple of ships were bought to transport those…significant infrastructure put in place to address that envisioned launch market.” – John Elbon, COO, United Launch Alliance (ULA)

 

Advertisement
-

In reality, Boeing was so desperate to secure USAF launches – despite the fact that it knew full well that Delta IV was too expensive to be sustainably competitive – that dozens of employees were eventually roped into a systematic, years-long, highly-illegal program of corporate espionage specifically designed to beat out government launch competitor Lockheed Martin. Humorously, Delta IV was not even Boeing’s design – rather, Boeing acquired designer McDonnell Douglas in late 1996, five days before the USAF announced the decision to reject Boeing and another company’s EELV proposals, narrowing down to two finalists (McDonnell Douglas and Lockheed Martin).

Seven years after the original lawsuit snowballed, Boeing settled with Lockheed Martin for a payment of more than $600M in 2006, accepting responsibility for its employees’ actions but admitting no corporate wrongdoing. Five years after that settlement, John Elbon became Vice President of Boeing’s Space Exploration division. This is by no means to suggest that Elbon is in any way complicit, having spent much of his 30+ years at Boeing managing the company’s involvement in the International Space Station, but more serves as an example of how recent these events are and why their consequences almost certainly continue to reverberate loudly within the US space industry.

SpaceX forces change

Worsened significantly by the consequences of Boeing’s lies about the actual operational costs of its Delta IV rocket (it had planned to secretly write off a loss on each rocket in order to steal USAF market share from LockMart), the commercial market for the extremely expensive rocket was and still is functionally nonexistent. 35 out of the family’s 36 launches have been contracted by the US military (30), NOAA (3), or NASA (2); the rocket’s first launch, likely sold at a major discount to Eutelsat, remains its one and only commercial mission.

ULA’s Delta Heavy seen during the August 2018 launch of NASA’s Parker Solar Probe. (Tom Cross)

Atlas V, typically priced around 30% less than comparable Delta IV variants, has had a far more productive career, albeit with very few commercial launches since the Dec. 2006 formation of the United Launch Alliance. Since 2007, just 5 of Atlas V’s 70 launches have been for commercial customers. Frankly, although Atlas V was appreciably more affordable than Delta IV, neither rocket was ever able to sustainably compete with Europe’s Ariane 5 workhorse – Ariane 5 cost more per launch, but superior payload performance often let Arianespace manifest two large satellites on a single launch, approximately halving the cost for each customer. Russia’s affordable (but only moderately reliable) Proton rockets also played an important role in the commercial launch industry prior to SpaceX’s arrival.

After fighting tooth and nail for years to break ULA’s US governmental launch monopoly, SpaceX’s first dedicated National Security Space launch finally occurred less than a year and a half ago, in May 2017. SpaceX has since placed a USAF spaceplane and a classified NSS-related satellite into orbit and been awarded launch contracts for critical USAF payloads, most notably winning five of five competed GPS III satellite launches, to begin as early as mid-December. Falcon 9 will cost the USAF roughly 30% less than a comparable Atlas 5 contract, $97M to ULA’s ~$135M.

 

Advertisement
-

A bit more than two decades after Boeing bought McDonnell Douglas and began a calculated effort to steal trade secrets from Lockheed Martin, Elbon – now COO of the Boeing/Lockheed Martin-cooperative ULA – seems to fervently believe that the most critical mistake made in the late 1990s and early 2000s was the USAF’s decision to partially support the development of two separate rockets. Elbon concluded his remarks on the topic with one impressively unambiguous summary of ULA’s position:

“We have to make sure that we don’t get too much supply and not enough demand so that the [launch] providers can’t survive in a robust business environment, and then we lose the capability as a country to do the launches we need to do … [That’s] the perspective we have at ULA and it’s based on the experience that we’ve been through in the past.”

In his sole Delta IV vs. Atlas V case-study, what ULA now seems to think might have been “too much supply” under the USAF’s EELV program appears to literally be the fundamental minimum conditions needed for competition to exist at all – two companies offering two competing products. Short of directly stating as much, it’s difficult to imagine a more concise method of revealing the apparent belief that competition – at all – is intrinsically undesirable or risky.

A recording of the Von Braun Symposium’s Commercial Space panel can be viewed here at timestamp 01:11:40.

Eric Ralph is Teslarati's senior spaceflight reporter and has been covering the industry in some capacity for almost half a decade, largely spurred in 2016 by a trip to Mexico to watch Elon Musk reveal SpaceX's plans for Mars in person. Aside from spreading interest and excitement about spaceflight far and wide, his primary goal is to cover humanity's ongoing efforts to expand beyond Earth to the Moon, Mars, and elsewhere.

Advertisement
TESLARATI MARKETPLACE LIMITED-TIME OFFER

Give the gift of Tesla upgrades.

Shop for someone else or treat yourself. Get more shopping power with a Teslarati gift card.

YOU PAY $250
+
FREE BONUS $75
$325 TOTAL VALUE
Digital gift card delivered by email. Promotional terms apply.
View gift card details →
Comments

News

Tesla Full Self-Driving v15: Reality View review, new features explained

Published

on

Tesla has officially started rolling out the Full Self-Driving version 15 update, and we were lucky enough to get it in the first wave on Saturday night. It comes with a lot of new features, but the biggest is Tesla Reality View, a real-time AI video generation of the outside world that uses less compute than even the earliest versions of FSD driving visualization.

The release notes, which we covered on Saturday, revealed Reality View, Speed Camera Recognition and Slowdown, and a new Bike Rack Mode.

After spending plenty of time with the suite over the last 18 hours, I have a pretty good grasp of the new features and what you should expect from them when you get them on your Tesla. CEO Elon Musk said that it will wide release in December with the 2026 Holiday Update.

Advertisement
-

NOTE: If you’re looking for a review on FSD v15.0.1’s driving performance, I will have a small section breaking down what I noticed over the first drives I took, but I would rather hold off on making any real declarations about it until I have a few hundred miles under my belt. It just feels like I can’t make any real distinctions on anything other than a handful of things Tesla claims in its release notes.

Tesla Reality Vision

Let’s start what I know we are all here for: Tesla Reality Vision is here and it’s absolutely insane. Elon and Co. have also shed a lot of really cool tidbits about the development of it and some of its more intimate details. It’s pretty remarkable what they’re saying about it.

My first impression of Reality View was that it was incredibly detailed. It is honestly hard to believe, at first glance, that there is not a drone following your car. However, once you reach any sort of signage, it’s pretty obvious that it is not a puzzling of camera angles but exactly what Musk says it is:

Advertisement
-

My first rides with it revealed quite a few things.

  • It’s very impressive how realistic the texturing of the environment is. The grass, trees, buildings, and all of nature is really well rendered. You can see the shifting as you are moving; I’ve seen a lot of people compare it to the early versions of the Will Smith Spaghetti AI Videos, and that feels like a good comparison. It’s very, very good for a first attempt, and if it looks like this now, it isn’t unrealistic to say that it will look very close to realistic in the future. I would think within the next 8 months is probably somewhat realistic.
  • There is some input lag, and Musk has already addressed that by stating: “Currently, the latency is a bit high due to compute constraints, but we have ways to interleave newer UVE features along the diffusion transformer layers to cut roughly 35% of the latency.”
    • The lag is not something that is a dealbreaker or even that bad, but it is definitely noticeable. It’s still much better than many OEMs UI, which is as simplistic as menus and has tremendously more lag. It sounds like Musk already has a plan that should alleviate this, so that could come soon.

Advertisement
-

One of the coolest features of the Reality View is that it will orient itself based on whether you’re moving forward or backward. When backing out of a space, the drone view switches to the front of the car:

Another really nice touch is the quieter turn signal chimes, which start at a normal volume and then subtly get quieter until they are barely noticeable. It’s a very peaceful touch that Tesla added with the v15 update:

First Thoughts on Driving Performance

Overall, I have only noticed a handful of things. Driving performance feels very similar to recent FSD versions, but these are two things I caught:

  • When taking a left-hand turn from the middle of an intersection with a lot of room, the car didn’t just turn left, it actually turned right a little bit and then turned left. This is something you see a lot of very inexperienced drivers do; they’ll be in a Honda Civic and they act like they need to swing it wide to make a very straightforward turn. I have never seen FSD do this. This turn is one I take each day, as it is on my way to the gym. It was absolutely crazy and I was really thrown off by it. I hope this isn’t a new thing.
  • I didn’t get to see many potholes but I did see a lot of manhole covers, and FSD didn’t do anything to avoid them. In our YouTube video down below, you’ll notice it runs over many manhole covers. I was hoping it was try to avoid these, but I didn’t seem to get that impression.

In the coming days, I’ll do a longer review on the driving performance and whether or not v15.0.1 includes the things that Tesla explicitly mentioned in the Release Notes.

Continue Reading

Elon Musk

Tesla Full Self-Driving v15 rollout begins: full release notes and improvements

Published

on

Tesla Reality View with FSD v15 (Credit: Tesla)

Tesla has announced that Full Self-Driving version 15 is now rolling out, after CEO Elon Musk said earlier today that the wide rollout would occur in December.

Now, Tesla is rolling out to Early Access Program (EAP) members v15’s first builds, and there are a lot of new improvements.

Tesla explicitly stated that safety improvements come in the form of “25x better handling of safety critical cases.” It is also rolling out “Tesla Reality View,” a new version of the Driver Visualization that appears to be much more realistic and could potential use Unreal Engine, according to the teaser video Tesla posted on social media. This “adds a live visualization of the drive that lets you see & control what FSD is planning to do.”

Advertisement
-

Perhaps the biggest improvements that Tesla mentioned, however, are that of Navigation fixes and better detection and aversion from potholes, debris, and animals, as well as “more natural speed handling in school zones and inclement weather.”

Tesla also added a new “Bike Rack Mode,” which will enable FSD’s use when bike racks or other hitch accessories are attached.

Tesla also revealed the full Release Notes for v15:

  • Upgraded vision encoder shared between FSD, Robotaxi, and Optimus, which is trained on millions of internet videos for improved generalization and data efficiency, improving the critical intervention rate by 25x.
  • Introduced Tesla Augmented Reality, replacing all of the explicit model signals into a single end-to-end visualization using less total compute.
  • Improved navigation by using an end-to-end learned model based on route preference data from the fleet.
  • Improved parking location selection by using personalized parking history, and the map will now display multiple parking options at your destination.
  • Improved driver monitoring by increasing vision-based attention monitoring availability with hats and sunglasses and decreasing strictness in higher speed driver profiles.
  • Improved detection of road signs, small animals, road debris, and chains.
  • Improved detection of potholes, road details, and avoidance of deep standing water.
  • Improved speed handling for each driver profile, school zones and speed limits, and inclement weather.
  • Improved Autoshift functionality by unifying with FSD-based gear predictions.
  • Tesla Reality View New: real-time generative driving visualization that continuously streams a view from an arbitrary virtual camera situated above your vehicle, enabling you to see and control what FSD is planning to do. Select between fullscreen visualizations, maps or a split view – or choose quiet mode for a calming cabin experience. Upcoming navigation turns display directly in the driving visualization. Turn signals are quieter and fade out after a few clicks.
  • Speed Camera Slowdown: FSD (Supervised) can now slow down when it detects a speed camera. Press the accelerator or increase your speed profile to cancel the slowdown. If you cancel twice at the same camera, your Tesla saves that location and will not slow down there again. To remove saved cameras, go to Controls > Service > Manage Saved Locations.
  • Bike Rack Mode With Bike Rack Mode, you can now engage FSD (Supervised) when a bike rack or similar hitch accessory is installed. When Bike Rack Mode is enabled, FSD (Supervised) pulls over near your destination and does not reverse. Autopark, Summon, and Backup chimes and warnings will be disabled.

It sounds like there are some really great improvements, and this is probably just a handful of what other improvements will come from these upgrades. For example, the UI changes will likely come with some other features that will be discovered upon the public having hands-on experience with it.

Musk said this morning that a wide release would occur sometime in December.

We’re looking forward to testing it when it arrives to us!

Advertisement
-

Continue Reading

Elon Musk

Tesla Full Self-Driving v15 gets release date from Elon Musk

Published

on

Tesla Full Self-Driving v15 has received an official release date from CEO Elon Musk, who says the newest and most capable version of the suite will go wide in December with the 2026 Holiday Update.

That means the first iterations of the suite could actually come sooner, as the Early Access Program is the initial batch of owners to receive a new FSD release. Musk’s comments released a few tidbits of information, but nothing overwhelmingly revealing about its capabilities.

Musk was talking about supervised fine-tuning, stating that it is like “getting a haircut with a chainsaw,” before stating that FSD v15 will roll out wide for owners next month:

Musk’s Confirmed Changes and Fixes

Musk simply confirmed the new Full Self-Driving version would roll out with the 2026 Holiday Update, and the only two explicit changes he confirmed were updates to the User Interface (UI) and two small changes.

Musk’s comments on the UI confirm there are big changes coming to it, as he stated:

Advertisement
-

The UI changes will likely upgrade AMD Ryzen-equipped Tesla vehicles running AI4 to visualize vehicles using the Unreal Engine, something that was found in coding last year:

Tesla plans to use Unreal Engine for driver visualization with crazy upgrade

Advertisement
-

Additionally, one user stated that their biggest complaints with v14’s most recent releases is that they have to “stop refusing to use the HOV lane” and last-second lane changes to merge or turn happen too frequently. Musk said these should be fixed in v15.

In the past, we’ve also gotten small bits of detail about the v15 release, including from Tesla’s Head of AI, Ashok Elluswamy, who stated back in September that there are improved safety and collision avoidance systems coming with the v15 release.

Tesla plans big safety improvements for Full Self-Driving v15

Advertisement
-

The big prediction for v15 is whether this will enable at least some unsupervised driving in personal Teslas. There are likely to be some massive jumps in capability, although FSD has already proven itself to be a great way to travel. Nevertheless, there are a lot of things it could do better.

FSD still struggles with parking, it has routine bugs from update to update, it does not recognize potholes or large bumps on the road, speed control is a common complaint, and Navigation has been one of the biggest pain points.

However, v15 will likely bring massive improvements to capability and give people more options, like potentially parking orientation and more refined spot selection. We can only wait and see what Tesla will include.

Advertisement
-
Continue Reading