Connect with us

Investor's Corner

Tesla’s (TSLA) fundamentals ‘underappreciated,’ says analyst amid canceled privatization drama

Published

on

Tesla stock (NASDAQ:TSLA) is showing its trademark volatility on Monday’s early morning trading, as the company deals with the aftermath of Elon Musk’s decision to walk back on his efforts to take the company private. While the electric car maker’s shares dropped as low as 6% during Monday’s premarket, Tesla nonetheless opened at $318 per share, not too far from Friday’s $322.82 close.

Tesla’s stock has been characteristically volatile, but after Musk’s fateful tweet earlier this month when he suggested that funding was “secured” for the company going private at $420 per share, TSLA has experienced even wilder swings than usual. The company’s privatization efforts eventually came to a head on Friday night, when Elon Musk published a blog post on Tesla’s official website stating that the privatization efforts would no longer be pursued. Musk’s decision was met with strong reactions, with many Tesla supporters lauding the CEO’s decision and critics voicing out their frustrations.

Tesla’s abandonment of its go-private initiative has resulted in a wave of criticism from the company’s naysayers. Prominent short-seller Jim Chanos, who believes that TSLA is worth $0, described the company as a “corporate-governance disaster.” Jeffrey Osborne of Cowen Group noted that he sees “mounting obstacles for the company” in the near future such such shareholder lawsuits and SEC investigations over Elon Musk’s behavior.

That said, some of Tesla’s supporters on Wall Street believe that there is a silver lining to the entire go-private drama. Baird analyst Ben Kallo, for one, stated in note on Monday that Baird remains optimistic about Tesla, especially since the company’s fundamentals, which have been steadily improving, might be “underappreciated.” Kallo did admit that a potential SEC penalty would likely weigh against Tesla, though if this does happen, Elon Musk himself would probably be the one who would bear the consequences.

“We expect shares to appreciate over the intermediate term as the focus shifts back to fundamentals, which we believe may be underappreciated. We are buyers on weakness as we expect shares to move higher ahead of third-quarter deliveries and results. A potential SEC penalty will remain an overhang; while it is extremely difficult to predict the outcome of an investigation, historical settlements may demonstrate perceived risks could be overblown. Additionally, we think any penalties will likely be borne by Musk.”

Advertisement

Kallo still maintained his Outperform rating for Tesla, setting a price target of $411 for the electric car maker.

Oppenheimer’s Colin Rusch also maintained his Outperform rating for the company. According to the analyst, stepping away from the go-private initiative “removes a large distraction that had significant chance of failure and the potential to severely limit Tesla’s access to capital while attempting to execute on its ambitious product strategy.” RBC Capital Markets analyst Joseph Spak also noted that while Tesla and Elon Musk’s credibility have taken a hit due to the CEO’s behavior on Twitter, the firm believes that “the story will come back to the Model 3 ramp — not just the units but the profitability.”

The Model 3 ramp has been showing encouraging signs this August. Apart from Elon Musk confirming during the Q2 2018 earnings call that Tesla was able to hit a production rate of 5,000 Model 3 per week during “multiple weeks” in July, the company also passed the 100,000-mark in its VIN registrations for the electric sedan. Analysts from Evercore ISI who toured the Fremont factory also released a favorable report, stating that Tesla has the potential to ramp production to 7,000-8,000 Model 3 per week with “very little incremental capital expenditure.” 

As of writing, Tesla stock is trading -3.15% at $312.73 per share.

Disclosure: I have no ownership in shares of TSLA and have no plans to initiate any positions within 72 hours.

Advertisement

Simon is an experienced automotive reporter with a passion for electric cars and clean energy. Fascinated by the world envisioned by Elon Musk, he hopes to make it to Mars (at least as a tourist) someday. For stories or tips--or even to just say a simple hello--send a message to his email, simon@teslarati.com or his handle on X, @ResidentSponge.

Comments

Investor's Corner

Tesla “best positioned” for Trump tariffs among automakers: analyst

Ives has a price target of $315 per share for the electric vehicle maker.

Published

on

Credit: Tesla

Wedbush analyst Dan Ives recently shared his thoughts about Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) amidst the Trump administration’s tariffs. As per Ives, Tesla is best-positioned relative to its rivals when it comes to the ongoing tariff issue.

Ives has a price target of $315 per share for the electric vehicle maker.

Best Positioned

During an interview with Yahoo Finance, the segment’s hosts asked about his thoughts on Tesla, especially considering Musk’s work with the Trump administration. Musk has previously stated that the effects of tariffs on Tesla are significant due to parts that are imported from abroad.

“When it comes to the tariff issue, they are actually best positioned relative to the Detroit Big Three and others and obviously foreign automakers. Still impacted, Musk has talked about that, in terms of just auto parts,” Ives stated.

China and Musk

Ives also stated that ultimately, a big factor for Tesla in the coming months may be the Chinese market’s reactions to its tariff war. He also noted that the next few quarters will be pivotal for Tesla considering the brand damage that Elon Musk has incited due to his politics and work with the Trump administration.

Advertisement

“When it comes to Tesla, I think the worry is where does retaliatory look like in China, in terms of buying domestic. I think that’s something that’s a play. And they have a pivotal six months head, in terms of what everything we see in Austin, autonomous, and the buildout. 

“But the brand issues that Musk self-inflicted is dealing with in terms of demand destruction in Europe and the US. And that’s why this is a key few quarters ahead for Tesla and also for Musk to make, in my opinion, the right decision to take a step back from the administration,” Ives noted.

Continue Reading

Investor's Corner

Tesla negativity “priced into the stock at its current levels:” CFRA analyst

The CFRA analyst has given Tesla a price target of $360 per share.

Published

on

Credit: Tesla China

In recent comments to the Schwab Network, CFRA analyst Garrett Nelson stated that a lot of the “negative sentiment towards Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) is priced into the stock at its current levels.”

The CFRA analyst has given Tesla a price target of $360 per share.

Q1 A Low Point in Sales

The CFRA analyst stated that Tesla’s auto sales likely bottomed last quarter, as noted in an Insider Monkey report. This was, Nelson noted, due to Q1 typically being the “weakest quarter for automakers.” He also highlighted that all four of Tesla’s vehicle factories across the globe were idled in the first quarter.

While Nelson highlighted the company’s changeover to the new Model Y as a factor in Q1, he also acknowledged the effects of CEO Elon Musk’s politics. The analyst noted that while Tesla lost customers due to Musk’s political opinions, the electric vehicle maker has also gained some new customers in the process.

CFRA’s Optimistic Stance

Nelson also highlighted that Tesla’s battery storage business has been growing steadily over the years, ending its second-best quarter in Q1 2025. The analyst noted that Tesla Energy has higher margins than the company’s electric vehicle business, and Tesla itself has a very strong balance sheet.

Advertisement

The CFRA analyst also predicted that Tesla could gain market share in the United States because it has less exposure to the Trump administration’s tariffs. Teslas are the most American-made vehicles in the country, so the Trump tariffs’ effects on the company will likely be less notable compared to other automakers that produce their cars abroad.

Continue Reading

Investor's Corner

Tesla average transaction prices (ATP) rise in March 2025: Cox Automotive

Tesla Model Y and Model 3 saw an increase in their average transaction price (ATP) in March 2025.

Published

on

Credit: Tesla/X

Data recently released from Cox Automotive’s Kelley Blue Book has revealed that electric vehicles such as the Tesla Model Y and Model 3 saw an increase in their average transaction price (ATP) in March 2025.

Cox Automotive’s findings were shared in a press release

March 2025 EV ATPs

As noted by Cox, new electric vehicle prices in March were estimated to be $59,205, a 7% increase year-over-year. In February, new EV prices had an ATP of $57,015. The average transaction price for electric vehicles was 24.7% higher than the overall auto industry ATP of $47,462.

As per Cox, “Compared to the overall industry ATP ($47,462), EV ATPs in March were higher by nearly 25% as the gap between new ICE and new EV grows wider. EV incentives continued to range far above the industry average. In March, the average incentive package for an EV was 13.3% of ATP, down from the revised 14.3% in February.”

Tesla ATPs in Focus

While Tesla saw challenges in the first quarter due to its factories’ changeover to the new Model Y, the company’s ATPs last month were estimated at $54,582, a year-over-year increase of 3.5% and a month-over-month increase of 4.5%. A potential factor in this could be the rollout of the Tesla Model Y Launch Series, a fully loaded, limited-edition variant of the revamped all-electric crossover that costs just under $60,000.

This increase, Cox noted, was evident in Tesla’s two best-selling vehicles, the Model 3 sedan and the Model Y crossover, the best-selling car globally in 2023 and 2024. “ATPs for Tesla’s two core models – Model 3 and Model Y – were higher month over month and year over year in March,” Cox wrote.

Advertisement

Cox’s Other Findings

Beyond electric vehicles, Cox also estimated that new vehicle ATPs held steady month-over-month and year-over-year in March at $47,462, down slightly from the revised-lower ATP of $47,577 in February. Sales incentives in March were flat compared to February at 7% of ATP, though they are 5% higher than 2024, when incentives were equal to 6.7% of ATP. 

Estimates also suggest that new vehicle sales in March topped 1.59 million units, the best volume month in almost four years. This was likely due to consumers purchasing cars before the Trump administration’s tariffs took effect. As per Erin Keating, an executive analyst at Cox, all things are pointing to higher vehicle prices this summer. 

“All signs point to higher prices this summer, as existing ‘pre-tariff’ inventory is sold down to be eventually replaced with ‘tariffed’ inventory. How high prices rise for consumers is still very much to be determined, as each automaker will handle the price puzzle differently. Should the White House posture hold, our team is expecting new vehicles directly impacted by the 25% tariff to see price increases in the range of 10-15%,” Keating stated.

Continue Reading

Trending